Is the “Sunday Obligation” Unreasonably Harsh?

by MATT NELSON

Some Catholics, especially parents of young children, find Sunday Mass attendance difficult.

As a parent of a spirited three-year-old and a busy one-year-old who loves to show off her prodigious screaming ability, I get it.But despite our parental hardships, we recognize that we have a moral duty to be there.  The Catholic Church reflects this obligation in its Code of Canon Law: “On Sundays and other holy days of obligation, the faithful are bound to participate in the Mass” (can. 1247).  The Sunday liturgy is mandatory, like showing up for work; and, just as skipping work can have serious consequences, so can skipping church.  In fact, it is a mortal sin to miss Sunday Mass without good reason.  For a Catholic then, whether or not to attend on Sunday is no small decision.

But is the “Sunday obligation” too strict of an expectation upon Catholics?

 Rules to live by

Moral laws are like signposts: they properly orient us, and once we have been properly oriented we cease to notice them.  The first time I traveled to Calgary I needed to follow the signs; they told me where to go and thus imposed a direction upon me.  That was a long time ago.  Years later, I know how to get there without the aid of signs.  I have been properly oriented.  The signs are still there — they still hold their objective force — but I no longer notice them.  They are unimposing.

Likewise, the Sunday obligation helps to orient us spiritually.  It can be easy to forget that Sunday marks the beginning of our week, not the end.  In a sense, the Sunday Mass prepares us for the days ahead and sets the spiritual tone for the week, filling us with God’s word and grace so we might glorify the Lord with our lives.  By starting our week with the Sunday liturgy, we publicly profess with our whole being that we are sons and daughters of God and members of his Church.  We are God’s first.  Without him we are nothing.

That is why Jesus can say, “He who loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; and he who loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me” (Matt. 10:37).  Furthermore, the first and greatest commandment is, “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind” (Matt. 22:38).  Our unique love for God (and his for us!) is specially consummated when we receive the Eucharist at Mass.

The Mass is challenging

A Catholic is permitted to be absent from Sunday Mass in light of serious circumstances such as illness.  But it is not licit to skip for trivial reasons.  We might be tempted to do this, nonetheless, because Mass is not always an engaging way to spend Sunday morning.  Many of us lead dynamic lives.  We are used to the continual stimulation of caffeine and conversation.  We are not used to the slowness or the silence of the liturgy.  We are not used to the language of the Bible readings and the prayers.  Even for a devout Catholic, it can be difficult to slow down and settle into a day of rest — and especially into a solemn hour of prayer and worship.

The essential moral prescription of the third commandment nonetheless remained: man ought to set apart a full day each week for rest and worship. 

We can’t grasp the intrinsic value of the Mass until we understand that its aim is not to stimulate like a form of entertainment: its aim is to sanctify.  Although the Eucharist is the “source and summit of the Christian life” according to the Catechism, it is not uncommon for a Catholic — through no fault of his own — to feel almost nothing when he receives it (1324).  Since the grace received in the Eucharist is not a physical or emotional sensation but a spiritual reality, it tends to leave the senses unmoved.  For this reason, a Catholic’s experience of Sunday Mass can be deceptively dry and may leave him feeling like nothing special has gone on at all.  This does not necessarily reflect a defect in the liturgy or the believer.  Rather, it moves the Catholic to a deeper mental conviction of things not seen: “Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe” (John 20:29).

The Mass presents an essential challenge to Catholics: in its slow and leisurely rhythm, in its moments of deep silence, in its demands of faith.  Two grave dangers to the human soul are a lack of contemplation and lack of love.  A human being cannot have enduring happiness without these two things.  The Mass fosters both.

What happens at Mass

To remember the Sabbath and keep it holy was not optional for the first-century Jew.  To fail to do so was a violation of the third commandment and a grave sin (Num. 15:32-36).  Christians replaced the Sabbath, the last day of the week, with a new day of rest that they called the Lord’s Day, the first day of the week.  The essential moral prescription of the third commandment nonetheless remained: man ought to set apart a full day each week for rest and worship.  “Think not that I have come to abolish the law and the prophets; I have come not to abolish them but to fulfill them,” Jesus said (Matt. 5:17).

Why Sunday?  We are told in the Gospels that Jesus rose from the dead “on the first day of the week” (Mark 16:2; Luke 24:1; John 20:1), and ever since the time of the apostles Christians have congregated on Sunday to worship God and receive the Eucharist together as one body in Christ (Acts 20:7).  To compound this, it is primarily in the act of receiving the Sunday Eucharist — the real body, blood, soul, and divinity of Christ — that the members of the Church unite themselves to their Lord and one other.  Hence, St. Paul writes, “Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread” (1 Cor. 10:17).

Every Sunday “the whole Christ” is reunited in and through the Holy Eucharist.  Moreover, our choice to participate is salvific: “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you” (John 6:53).  Theologian Colin Donovan reminds us that “in the Mass it is Christ himself who worships the Father, joining our worship to his.  In no other way is it possible to adequately give thanks (eucharistia) to God . . . than by uniting our offerings to that of Jesus Christ himself.” Christ does with us in the Mass what we cannot do alone: make a perfect offering to the Father.

The key to understanding why Catholics must attend Sunday Mass lies above all in the essence of the Mass itself.  Our duty to be willing participants is not rooted in how it makes us feel but in what it is.  As the sacred meeting place of God and man, the Mass reorients our lives towards God, reunites us with him in love, and thereby communicates the grace of salvation to our souls.  In the long run, there can be nothing more productive than that.

Acknowledgement

cacMatt Nelson. “Is the “Sunday Obligation” Unreasonably Harsh?” Catholic Answers (August 10, 2017). Reprinted with permission from Catholic Answers. The premier magazine of Catholic apologetics and evangelization for more than two decades, Catholic Answers Magazine helps build your faith and your ability to defend it. Go here to find out more.

The Author

nelsonMatt Nelson holds a B. Ed. in physical education from the University of Regina and is a graduate of Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College. After several years of skepticism, he returned to the Catholic Church in 2010. Matt blogs at ReasonableCatholic.com, and his writing has appeared at WordOnFire.org and StrangeNotions.com. He is also a speaker for Face to Face Ministries. Matt lives with his wife, Amanda, and their three children in Saskatchewan, Canada.

Copyright © 2017 Catholic Answers Magazine